⌘ K
"A near-consensus crowd-pleaser that earns its Recommended BrickScore of 81.9 through an innovative cannon mechanism, dramatic all-black presence, and a build that delights from start to finish, held back only by a price that most reviewers feel runs $30 to $50 too high."
Reviewers and owners are in strong agreement that Captain Jack Sparrow's Pirate Ship (10365) is one of the best large LEGO ships in recent memory, earning a BrickScore of 81.9 and an owner average of 4.82 across 589 buyers with 92% recommending it. The all-black hull, working cannon broadside mechanism, and impressively tall finished model are cited consistently as standout achievements. The main tension in reviews is over price, with expert value consensus at 58.2 and some reviewers calling it $50 too expensive, though owner value-for-money data from LEGO's platform scores a healthier 4.1 out of 5.
Where they split: Agreement is high on quality; the only real divergence is on whether the price is acceptable. Fans who love the source material tend to find the price defensible, while more price-conscious reviewers recommend waiting for a sale or compare it unfavorably to other large ships at lower price-per-piece ratios.
Is this a smart buy? BrickPicker's data-grounded investment verdict.
Unlock the Max Profit Opinion: our stance (buy / accumulate / hold / pass), the reasoning, the exact data behind it (eBay + BrickLink comps, CAGR vs MSRP, our retirement model), and whether the reviewer community agrees.
"This isn't the Black Pearl we got in 2010. That set was a showcase build, all sail and silhouette. This 2025 version is something different: a functional ship that actually works as a playset."
The Earl of Bricks
"Here is the most thorough, most detailed, most intriguing and most rewarding LEGO Pirate set you will have ever built"
Brick Fanatics"This isn't the Black Pearl we got in 2010. That set was a showcase build, all sail and silhouette. This 2025 version is something different: a functional ship that actually works as a playset."
"Here is the most thorough, most detailed, most intriguing and most rewarding LEGO Pirate set you will have ever built"
Amazon4.9
LEGO.com4.7Walmart4.9
