About Halloween Hayride

LEGO 40423 Halloween Hayride is part of the LEGO Seasonal Halloween theme, contains 148 pieces, includes 3 minifigures. Its original US MSRP was $12.99. BrickPicker tracks live retailer pricing across Amazon, Walmart, Target and LEGO.com, eBay sold history, BrickLink part-out value, retirement forecasts and an investment score for Halloween Hayride.

Answered live from BrickPicker’s market tracking, review analysis and retirement model — these update as the data does.

What is LEGO 40423 Halloween Hayride worth today?

BrickPicker currently values a sealed Halloween Hayride at $33.99, based on 8 eBay sales over the last 180 days. That is 162% above its original $12.99 US retail price. The full price history is on this page.

How has LEGO 40423 Halloween Hayride performed compared with its retail price?

Since retiring, it has appreciated about 162% over its $12.99 retail price, with sealed copies now trading around $33.99. BrickPicker subscribers get the full Max Profit analysis for this set, which weighs eBay sold trends, retirement timing, liquidity and reviewer sentiment into one verdict.

Is LEGO 40423 Halloween Hayride retired?

Yes. Halloween Hayride retired in March 2024. Once retired, sets are only available on the aftermarket, which BrickPicker tracks through eBay sold prices and BrickLink listings.

How good is LEGO 40423 Halloween Hayride according to reviews?

Halloween Hayride holds a BrickScore of 77 (Recommended), the consensus of 5 expert reviews from 5 sources. Owners rate it 4.9/5 across 8 buyer ratings. Read the full review analysis →