Most Valuable Pirates LEGO Sets of the 1990s

The most valuable Pirates LEGO sets from the 1990s by current market value. This list ranks 49 sets by current BrickPicker value, refreshed from live market data. Right now the top spot belongs to Skull's Eye Schooner at $5,999. The top 5 alone account for about 52% of the value on this list. Every entry links to its full price history and marketplace listings. Updated 2026-07-22.

#	Name	Value	Growth	/ piece
1	Skull's Eye Schooner Pirates · 1993	$5,999	+4642%	$6.58
2	Imperial Trading Post Pirates · 1992	$2,300	+2606%	$3.78
3	Pirates Perilous Pitfall Pirates · 1997	$1,899	+2501%	$4.81
4	Rock Island Refuge Pirates · 1991	$1,847	+2699%	$4.85
5	Red Beard Runner Pirates · 1996	$1,635	+1551%	$2.33
6	Enchanted Island Pirates · 1994	$1,377	+1986%	$3.22
7	Imperial Flagship Pirates · 1992	$1,250	+2399%	$3.94
8	Skull Island Pirates · 1995	$857	+1517%	$2.27
9	Armada Flagship Pirates · 1996	$770	+1439%	$2.71
10	Renegade Runner Pirates · 1993	$650	+1535%	$3.65
11	Cross Bone Clipper Pirates · 1997	$650	+1870%	$4.22
12	Lagoon Lock-Up Pirates · 1991	$625	+2054%	$3.24
13	Barnacle Bay Value Pack Pirates · 1994	$425	—	$4.78
14	Forbidden Cove Pirates · 1994	$425	+1329%	$1.99
15	Imperial Outpost Pirates · 1995	$400	+1354%	$1.85
16	Shipwreck Island Pirates · 1996	$345	+1060%	$1.60
17	Pirate Lookout Pirates · 1992	$315	+15733%	$18.53
18	King Kahuka's Throne Pirates · 1994	$313	+1389%	$2.14
19	Sea Mates Pirates · 1993	$304	+4100%	$9.52
20	Treasure Chest Pirates · 1995	$300	+1264%	$1.89
21	Buccaneers Pirates · 1997	$275	+3974%	$7.64
22	Pirates Ambush Pirates · 1997	$264	+1102%	$1.69
23	Raft Raiders Pirates · 1992	$235	+1674%	$2.90
24	Cannon Cove Pirates · 1993	$200	+1043%	$1.89
25	Rocky Reef Pirates · 1995	$200	+1234%	$1.94
26	Islander Catamaran Pirates · 1994	$190	+1486%	$3.02
27	Pirates Treasure Pirates · 1994	$164	+2633%	$3.64
28	Volcano Island Pirates · 1996	$163	+1255%	$1.37
29	Broadside's Brig Pirates · 1991	$158	+1700%	$2.32
30	Smuggler's Shanty Pirates · 1992	$134	+1353%	$1.92
31	Soldiers Forge Pirates · 1994	$126	+3045%	$4.48
32	Bounty Boat Pirates · 1992	$120	+2426%	$3.33
33	Pirates Plunder Pirates · 1993	$120	+3912%	$5.71
34	Armada Sentry Pirates · 1996	$111	+1171%	$1.57
35	Battle Cove Pirates · 1992	$103	+3349%	$3.97
36	Renegade's Raft Pirates · 1991	$100	+2977%	$2.63
37	Crocodile Cage Pirates · 1994	$100	+1279%	$1.69
38	Shipwrecked Pirate Pirates · 1994	$94	+4606%	$4.07
39	King Kahuka Pirates · 1994	$90	+2156%	$2.00
40	Skeleton Crew Pirates · 1996	$80	+2575%	$2.86
41	Tidy Treasure Pirates · 1996	$68	+3317%	$3.09
42	Shipwrecked Pirate Pirates · 1994	$60	+2915%	$2.61
43	Treasure Surprise Pirates · 1996	$57	+2788%	$2.61
44	Pirates Gun Cart Pirates · 1993	$55	+1284%	$1.78
45	Pirate Lookout Pirates · 1992	$52	+2513%	$3.06
46	Pirates Desert Island Pirates · 1991	$46	+1438%	$2.19
47	Pirates Treasure Hold Pirates · 1992	$35	+1074%	$1.03
48	Imperial Cannon Pirates · 1994	$26	+374%	$0.72
49	Pirate's Cannon Pirates · 1994	$16	+298%	$0.99