Most Valuable Bionicle LEGO Sets of the 2000s

The most valuable Bionicle LEGO sets from the 2000s by current market value. This list ranks 50 sets by current BrickPicker value, refreshed from live market data. Right now the top spot belongs to Toa Mata Nui at $2,700. The top 5 alone account for about 33% of the value on this list. Every entry links to its full price history and marketplace listings. Updated 2026-07-22.

#	Name	Value	Growth	/ piece
1	Toa Mata Nui Bionicle · 2009	$2,700	+5301%	$7.38
2	Karzahni Bionicle · 2007	$1,550	+3775%	$4.15
3	Manas Bionicle · 2001	$800	+789%	$1.81
4	Ultimate Creatures Accessory Set Bionicle · 2006	$600	+2902%	$2.00
5	Skopio XV-1 Bionicle · 2009	$520	+478%	$0.61
6	Shooter + Disk Bionicle · 2004	$468	—	$234.19
7	Toa Lhikan and Kikanalo Bionicle · 2004	$460	+1434%	$2.15
8	Takanuva Bionicle · 2003	$450	+1400%	$2.25
9	Maxilos and Spinax Bionicle · 2007	$435	+1350%	$1.70
10	Brutaka Bionicle · 2006	$405	+1926%	$2.10
11	Ultimate Accessory Set Bionicle · 2006	$400	+1235%	$0.80
12	Takanuva Bionicle · 2008	$400	+1234%	$1.50
13	Vezon & Fenrakk Bionicle · 2006	$388	+1192%	$1.38
14	Hydraxon Bionicle · 2007	$355	+1676%	$2.15
15	Cahdok and Gahdok Bionicle · 2002	$350	+483%	$0.55
16	Axonn Bionicle · 2006	$320	+1501%	$1.63
17	Lesovikk Bionicle · 2007	$320	+1501%	$2.15
18	Ultimate BIONICLE Accessory Kit Bionicle · 2005	$318	+960%	$0.64
19	Muaka & Kane-ra Bionicle · 2001	$311	+345%	$0.49
20	Toa Terrain Crawler Bionicle · 2007	$306	+338%	$0.45
21	Makuta Icarax Bionicle · 2008	$300	+1401%	$1.89
22	The Ultimate BIONICLE Set Bionicle · 2004	$300	+1401%	$0.43
23	Toa Vakama (SDCC 2004 exclusive) Bionicle · 2004	$300	+3655%	$6.25
24	Jaller and Gukko Bionicle · 2003	$294	+1373%	$1.71
25	Makuta Bionicle · 2003	$290	+1351%	$1.46
26	Mata Nui Bionicle · 2009	$287	+2109%	$5.52
27	Nocturn Bionicle · 2007	$280	+1768%	$2.41
28	Exo-Toa Bionicle · 2002	$280	+700%	$0.74
29	Tahu Bionicle · 2001	$277	+3861%	$8.39
30	BIONICLE Exclusive Accessories Bionicle · 2005	$268	+1241%	$0.67
31	Tarakava Bionicle · 2001	$262	+424%	$0.64
32	Umbra Bionicle · 2006	$260	+940%	$1.45
33	Takua and Pewku Bionicle · 2003	$253	+1163%	$1.14
34	Jetrax T6 Bionicle · 2008	$250	+400%	$0.59
35	Gadunka Bionicle · 2007	$230	+1051%	$1.31
36	Axalara T9 Bionicle · 2008	$222	+178%	$0.32
37	Nui-Jaga Bionicle · 2001	$220	+529%	$1.01
38	Piraka Stronghold Bionicle · 2006	$213	+183%	$0.33
39	Toa Matau Bionicle · 2004	$210	+2522%	$4.55
40	Thornatus V9 Bionicle · 2009	$209	+248%	$0.48
41	Roodaka Bionicle · 2005	$207	+937%	$0.89
42	Kopaka Bionicle · 2001	$200	+2761%	$6.06
43	Toa Hahli Bionicle · 2007	$199	+1892%	$3.37
44	Tuma Bionicle · 2008	$198	+893%	$1.06
45	Baranus V7 Bionicle · 2009	$196	+391%	$0.75
46	Tahu Nuva Bionicle · 2002	$186	+2233%	$5.18
47	Bionicle Master Builder Set Bionicle · 2002	$180	+1286%	$1.76
48	Toa Undersea Attack Bionicle · 2007	$180	+260%	$0.45
49	Nuju Bionicle · 2001	$177	—	$6.10
50	Bionicle Power Pack Bionicle · 2001	$175	+1070%	$17.54