AT-ST

"The AT-ST is a genuinely solid, satisfying UCS build that reviewers enjoyed constructing, but its BrickScore of 72.5 and Mixed Reviews tier reflect a real gap: at $199.99 with one under-printed minifigure and no Ewoks despite the Return of the Jedi theme running through the manual, the set asks buyers to supply their own imagination where the parts list should have delivered."

The AT-ST (75417) lands in Mixed Reviews territory with a BrickScore of 72.5, reflecting genuine tension between an enjoyable, solid build process and persistent concerns about price, minifigure quality, and missed play opportunities. Owner ratings average 4.64 across 451 buyers, higher than the expert score suggests, but LEGO's own signals show value for money at 3.82 out of 5 and play experience at 3.89, among the lower figures in the UCS Star Wars line. Reviewers consistently enjoyed building the set and praised its structural solidity, while repeatedly noting that $199.99 for a single Imperial AT-ST driver with no Ewoks feels like an incomplete package given the iconic Return of the Jedi context the set itself highlights in its instruction manual.

Where they split: The split between the build experience scores (consistently high among reviewers) and the value and minifigure scores (consistently lower) defines this set. Critics and owners both rate it more positively overall than the expert BrickScore of 67.8 implies, but the specific complaints about minifigure count and price are persistent enough to justify the Mixed Reviews designation.