The Phantom

"The Phantom earns affection from Rebels fans and gift-buyers alike, but its BrickScore of 58.8 reflects a set that works best as an accessory to a larger purchase rather than a standalone value proposition, and critical reviewers consistently flagged the price-to-piece ratio as a weak point."

Reviewers found The Phantom (75048) to be a charming, surprisingly feature-packed companion ship for the Star Wars Rebels line, with more interior detail and playability than its small size suggests. However, the BrickScore of 58.8 reflects honest concerns about value for money at $24.99 for 234 pieces, and critics placed it firmly in "accessory" territory that primarily makes sense alongside the larger Ghost set. Owner ratings tell a different story: buyers average 4.14 out of 5 across 37 ratings, with Walmart buyers particularly enthusiastic (4.71), though LEGO.com shoppers were more measured (3.66).

Where they split: The split between owner ratings and the expert BrickScore is notable. Consumer buyers, especially those purchasing as gifts for children, rated it very highly (4.14 average, 4.71 at Walmart), while expert analysis docked it on value for money (46.6) and overall scored it in Skip It territory at 58.8. Adult fans with critical eyes found the spring-loaded missile an eyesore and the price hard to justify standalone, while families and show fans were broadly delighted.