Penguin Mario Power-Up Pack

"With a BrickScore of 52.5, the Penguin Mario Power-Up Pack is a lovable but limited accessory — enthusiastic owner reviews celebrate its cute look and sliding sound effects, while more analytical reviewers note the gameplay upgrade is essentially illusory and the price-to-value ratio is hard to justify unless you're a committed completionist or shopping for a gift."

The Penguin Mario Power-Up Pack earns warm praise from most owners for its charming design and the satisfying belly-slide mechanic that triggers in-game sliding sounds and coin collection — making it a fun, affordable addition to any LEGO Super Mario setup. However, more critical reviewers push back hard on the actual gameplay value: the belly-slide earns no more coins than simply walking Mario in his default suit, and the flipper pieces have reported durability issues (falling off during play). The set is best understood as a cute costume accessory rather than a meaningful gameplay upgrade, and at its price point it feels marginal for non-completionists.

Where they split: Owners on LEGO.com rated it almost universally 5/5 and emphasized how fun the sliding mechanic and sound effects are. The Brickset reviewer took a sharply more critical stance, noting the belly-slide earns no gameplay advantage over the default suit and recommending buyers skip it in favor of expansion packs — a meaningful split between casual owner enthusiasm and measured critical analysis.