Magic Maze

"With a BrickScore of 66.6 and a real play mechanism that reviewers called unlike anything in LEGO's GWP history, Magic Maze is a Recommended novelty for those who enjoy a dexterity challenge; just know that owner ratings (3.84 on LEGO.com) reflect a genuine difficulty curve that will delight some and frustrate others."

The Magic Maze GWP (40596) is praised by reviewers as one of the most novel and genuinely playable gift-with-purchase sets LEGO has produced, earning a BrickScore of 66.6 Brothers Brick calls it 'unlike any other GWP I've encountered,' and Brickset describes it as 'quirky and fun.' Owner ratings tell a slightly more nuanced story: the Amazon average sits at 4.4 with a broader sample, while LEGO.com buyers gave it 3.84, and the would_recommend figure lands at 69%, indicating a real split between those who 'get' the game and those who find its difficulty frustrating. This is a Recommended set that has genuine replay value for patient builders but can frustrate those expecting a smooth experience.

Where they split: There is a mild split between the enthusiastic majority who love the challenge and novelty and a smaller group who found specific sections (the red steps, the Bridge of Impeccable Balance) too frustrating to enjoy. Some owners modified pieces to improve playability rather than accepting the design as built.