
"With a BrickScore of 66.9, the Mystic Witch is a fun, festive GWP that families and Halloween fans will enjoy, though expert reviewers note the flat backs and simplified construction hold it back from being a truly polished display piece."
The LEGO 40562 Mystic Witch earns a moderately positive reception overall, with buyer reviews overwhelmingly enthusiastic and expert reviewers more measured. The 3-in-1 Creator format is a notable highlight for a GWP, offering a witch, cat, and dragon — all Halloween-themed. While families and casual builders appreciate its festive charm and engaging build experience, more critical reviewers flag the flat, unfinished backs on all three models and the disappointing arm/hand construction on the witch as clear weaknesses.
Where they split: The sharpest split is between buyer reviewers (near-universal 5-star enthusiasm) and Hoth Bricks (a lukewarm "skip" verdict citing basic finish and poor part reuse on alternates). Brickset lands in the middle — positive with caveats. Expert reviewers also disagree on the broom: Brickset highlights it as a creative parts use, while Hoth Bricks wished it came in beige rather than green.

"40562 Mystic Witch will be free with purchases over £100 / $100 / €100 from the 14th to the 31st of October."
Brickset Reviews
"We can't blame this year on LEGO for its lack of inspiration for Halloween parties, even if the finish of the product remains really very basic."
Hoth Bricks
"40562 Mystic Witch will be free with purchases over £100 / $100 / €100 from the 14th to the 31st of October."

"We can't blame this year on LEGO for its lack of inspiration for Halloween parties, even if the finish of the product remains really very basic."
Amazon4.7
LEGO.com4.6