LEGO Reviews Creator31167

Haunted Mansion

Name: LEGO Haunted Mansion 31167
Brand: LEGO
SKU: 31167
Rating: 4.84 (792 reviews)

72 · RECOMMENDEDINVESTMENT GRADE: BBB2025736 pcsHigh agreement · 96%

Expert reviews

3analyzed

Owner ratings

792

Consensus

WAIT FOR SALE

BrickScore

Recommended

Owners

Synthesized Verdict

"A fun and feature-rich Halloween build with a genuinely great monster minifigure lineup, but the $89.99 price point draws consistent pushback and a surprisingly low 47% would-recommend rate that prospective buyers should weigh. Its BrickScore of 72 and 4.84-star average reflect a set that is enjoyable to build but priced at the upper edge of where it earns the value."

The Creator 3-in-1 Haunted Mansion (31167) earns a BrickScore of 72 in the Recommended tier, with owner reception strongly positive at 4.84 out of 5 across 792 ratings. Reviewers praised the three distinct Halloween-themed builds, the glow-in-the-dark ghost minifigure, and the set of five monster minifigures. The most notable tension is between the enthusiastic overall ratings and a strikingly low 47% would-recommend score on LEGO.com, which separates this set sharply from the other sets in this batch where that figure runs 82 to 100 percent.

Where they split: The 47% would-recommend rate on LEGO.com is in stark contrast to the high average rating of 4.84 stars, a split that is unusual in this batch. One likely explanation is that buyers enjoy building and displaying the set but hesitate to recommend it at its $89.99 price point, given competing Creator sets with stronger parts value. Critics and owners agree on the fun factor but diverge on whether the asking price is justified.

Where to Buy

Out of stock · 0% off

Affiliate links. We may earn a commission at no cost to you.

Max Profit Opinion PREMIUM

Is this a smart buy? BrickPicker's data-grounded investment verdict.

Unlock the Max Profit Opinion: our stance (buy / accumulate / hold / pass), the reasoning, the exact data behind it (eBay + BrickLink comps, CAGR vs MSRP, our retirement model), and whether the reviewer community agrees.

Unlock with Collector or Reseller

LOVED (7)

01Three complete builds in one box (haunted mansion, haunted pirate ship, and haunted train station with train)
02Glow-in-the-dark ghost minifigure as a standout special feature
03Five monster minifigures (Frankenstein, ghost, werewolf, vampire with two-sided head, skeleton with optional pirate hat)
04Hinged mansion that opens like a dollhouse for interior access
05Interactive elements including a rotating clock, moving ghost in the window, and a spinning element
06Solid and sturdy final build
07Accessible and well-organized numbered bag system

CRITICIZED (5)

01Price point of $89.99 for 736 pieces ($0.122 per piece) drew skepticism from several reviewers who suggested $50 to $60 would be more appropriate
02Value-for-money consensus among critics is 58.3/100, the weakest aspect score
03Owner would-recommend rate of only 47% on LEGO.com is unusually low for a set with high overall ratings, suggesting a meaningful split in buyer satisfaction
04Parts value consensus is a modest 62.3/100
05Playability consensus at 68.3/100 is moderate, with the main mansion build carrying more of that weight than the alternate builds

What reviewers are saying

"But does it measure up? Is it truly its spiritual successor?"

The Brothers Brick

"The details here are nice. The way it comes together is nice. I like everything about this. My only question is, is this worth $90?"

JANG's LEGO Reviews

"Great minifigures and a fun haunted house, if a little on the small side."

Brickset Reviews

Ecosystem

10228 Monster Fighters Haunted House — The new Creator set is much smaller in scale but offers a more affordable alternative for those who never had or cannot afford the original set at $400-$600 on the secondary market. At under $100 US, this is a pretty decent facsimile that captures the spirit of the beloved original while being accessible to a broader audience.

Monster Fighters Haunted House (2012) — While reviewer considers this a 'worthy successor' in design terms, it raises value questions. The 2012 set cost $180 USD at release (~$250 USD adjusted for inflation today), came with more minifigures, and was much larger (modular-sized with three floors). Current set at $90 represents higher relative pricing when accounting for inflation and reduced scope. Reviewer notes the difference in size doesn't make the new set worse, but the value comparison is unfavorable.

10228 Haunted House — 31167 is smaller and less substantial; colour scheme nods back to 10228; does not replace 10228 but could serve as nice annex. One commenter notes it's a 'budget version' of several retired sets (10228, 71042, 70424, 9467).

31175 Unicorn Castle — This haunted galleon is a much better rendition of a secondary 3-in-1 boat build than the fairytale version in 31175 Unicorn Castle

CreatorTier 1Investment Grade

By Reviewer · 3

Avg score

Consensus

WAIT FOR SALE

The Brothers Brick

Expert Video Source

BUY

"But does it measure up? Is it truly its spiritual successor?"

Key Pros

✓Five well-designed minifigures including a rare glow-in-the-dark ghost
✓Three distinct playable builds (mansion, train, ship) with unique features
✓Abundant sand green coloring throughout

Key Cons

✕Significantly smaller than the 2012 Monster Fighters 10228 Haunted House predecessor
✕Minimally furnished interior

JUMP TO REVIEW

JANG's LEGO Reviews

Expert Video Source

WAIT FOR SALE

"The details here are nice. The way it comes together is nice. I like everything about this. My only question is, is this worth $90?"

Key Pros

✓Excellent minifigure selection with detailed prints and good graphics
✓Compact, displayable design that looks good all around (front, sides)
✓Multiple display angles and mechanisms (ghost window, clock pendulum)

Key Cons

✕Price point of $90 USD seems high relative to content and inflation-adjusted predecessors
✕Alternate builds (train and pirate ship) are underwhelming and not as compelling

JUMP TO REVIEW

Brickset Reviews

Editorial Source

WAIT FOR SALE

"Great minifigures and a fun haunted house, if a little on the small side."

Key Pros

✓Great minifigures—better than many in dedicated monsters CMF ranges or previous incarnations
✓Detailed minifigures with glow-in-the-dark ghost
✓Excellent colour scheme (sand green and black)

Key Cons

✕Mansion a little on the small side, particularly when closed
✕Slightly disappointing secondary builds (ship and train less impressive than mansion)

READ FULL REVIEW

Dimensional Analysis

Investment Layer

Buy now (1)Wait for sale (2)

Value drivers

The Brothers Brick: Glow-in-the-dark ghost minifigure - extremely rare, last produced in 2015, currently worth approximately $30 on secondary markets

JANG's LEGO Reviews: Spooky Ghost - first ghost figure in a very long time with updated shroud and features

Exclusivity

The Brothers Brick: Wide retail release via LEGO.com and retailers (August 1st release)

Brickset Reviews: Wide retail; not LEGO.com exclusive

Resale

The Brothers Brick: Strong potential for resale value growth, particularly driven by the glow-in-the-dark ghost minifigure which currently commands ~$30 on the aftermarket. The set is positioned to maintain value as a more accessible entry point to the haunted house theme.

Brickset Reviews: Set not exclusive so should be available at decent discount before too long; already discounted at some retailers at review time. Commenters note Costco offered it at $67.99 vs RRP $89.99.

Minifigures & Standout Parts

In this set (5)

Ghost with Wavy Mouth

Vampire - Dark Red Dress, Black Hair

Frankenstein's Monster (Frankenstein)

Werewolf - Torn Red Flannel Shirt, Bare Chest with Fur and Muscles, Sand Blue Legs with Belt and Tears

Skeleton - Standard Skull, Bent Arms, Vertical Grip Left, Horizontal Grip Right

Standout parts (per reviewers)

Glow-in-the-dark ghost minifigure elementValue
Rare LEGO piece; only included in sets since at least 2015; highly sought after
Sand green coloring
Abundant throughout the set; collector appeal for those seeking this color in larger quantities
Ghost shroud with matte finishValue
Updated material with improved matte finish, includes mini peg hole for accessories, glows well
Printed minifigure torsos and facesValue
High-quality opacity prints on vampire (white skin on dark red), werewolf graphic design, detailed print work on torsos and legs
Organ build
Small detailed build element in center of upper floor
Grandfather clock with pendulum mechanism
Functional pendulum that swings via basic action feature

What Owners Say · summarized from 50 written reviews (LEGO, Amazon, Walmart)

Owners love the 3-in-1 versatility, creative design, and Halloween appeal, but consistently criticize the $89-90 price as too high for 700 pieces compared to past Monster Fighters sets.

COMMON PRAISE