R2-D2

"With a BrickScore of 75.8 and unanimous "buy" recommendations across all three reviews, the R2-D2 polybag (30611) is a clear win for Star Wars and polybag collectors alike — a surprisingly well-built, playable brick-built droid that justified the frenzy of its sold-out May the Fourth 2017 run."

All three reviewers recommend picking up set 30611 R2-D2, praising it as a charming and well-engineered polybag that punches above its weight for a free promotional item. The SNOT-built cylindrical body, rotating dome, articulated legs, and retractable central leg draw consistent applause, and the exclusive printed dome and front tile are considered genuine collectibles. Criticisms are largely proportional — the torso reads as slightly too wide, the back is plain, and the 5L Technic liftarms for the side legs can look awkward from certain angles. The promotional exclusivity (May the Fourth 2017, free with a qualifying £60+/€65+ Star Wars purchase) drove demand past supply and adds collectibility appeal for Star Wars and polybag enthusiasts.

Where they split: The main split is on whether the absence of an exclusive minifigure is a real loss. The Brick Fan and Brickset Reviews both note some fan disappointment but personally consider the brick-built model "more interesting than an obscure minifigure." Bouwsteentjes does not treat it as a negative at all. There is also mild disagreement on how significant the proportion issues are — Bouwsteentjes calls it "beautiful for the scale" while Brickset Reviews details specific awkward angles from the side legs.