BOGO 50% Return

Pseudoty · 2013-12-12T03:24:23.000Z

I purchased a BOGO 50% this weekend online Farnsworth House was $60 and the Seaside House was $50 promo marked down to $25 Total $85 that I used $50 in coinstar money towards and $35 on Paypal. Newb here and looked but did not see this but when I purchase BOGO in the store the discount is split between the two items. It was not online the discount was all on the SH. So I figured I would see what I would get on a return of the FH tonight. I got the full $60 on a gift card. I even asked the associate and she said it was because I used paypal? Is this normal and if so why not just buy and return one all the time, morals, they can ban you, or am I missing something? Best part is they had 2 HD in for $165 that they price matched online for $129 and I purchased them separately to get another $25 off each but the Wendy's promo would not work with price match they said.